PORTSMOUTHPOINT

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Gay Marriage: The Debate

Posted on 8:47 AM by Unknown
Today, the House of Commons debates a bill to legalise marriage between same-sex couples. From the Portsmouth Point archives, we present a debate on the subject of gay marriage.


George Hope argues that that the law must be changed to allow gay marriage:

"An interesting argument recalls the "separate but equal" claim, the exact words used by segregationists in America after the abolition of slavery. There is an illogical aspect to referring to civil partnerships and marriages as equal. If ‘marriage’ is a religious union, then the word should not be used to refer to non-religious marriages between a man and a woman. If it is not a religious term (my view) then marriages and civil partnerships are the same thing as long as equal rights are protected, so we should not use different words. Human beings are different. We come in different shapes and sizes, colours and creeds. Embrace difference, and don’t make the same mistakes that have divided and stigmatised humanity for generations."


Daniel Rollins counters that the Government has no mandate for passing gay marriage legislation:
 
"The government does not even have a democratic mandate to change the definition of marriage to extend it to same sex couples as the issue was not mentioned in any of the main party’s manifestos. This means that the people who will be affected by this change have not had a chance tell the government whether they agree with the idea or not, with opinion polls split and many showing support for the current definition of marriage the government can’t say that they are listening to what the people are saying about this change. The consultation they are having at the moment is also very undemocratic; it is not asking what people think of the proposed changes but only how to implement the changes, not allowing people to voice their opinions is contrary to all the ideas of democracy that the government tries to uphold."

Lucy Cole wonders whether marriage itself is now an outdated institution:

"Divorce rates are higher than ever, with one in three couples splitting after having vowed to love one another forever. We are constantly bombarded with news of celebrity couples desperately in love and getting married one second, and the next fighting over their divorce settlement. Perhaps this is the problem; in placing the basis of marriage on love we are setting up to fail, because, ultimately, very rarely does love last forever. For the most part it comes and goes, lasting a few months or years, but inevitably as we grow and develop, it fades."
 
 
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Blog Exclusive, Current Affairs | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Recipe: Fifteens
     by Patrick McGuiggan The definitive Northern Ireland traybake is the ‘Fifteen’. They are so delicious I assumed that they would be fairly ...
  • 'Porphyria's Lover': A Feminist Reading
    Josh Rampton offers a Feminist reading of Robert Browning's poem 'Porphyria's Lover'. This article was originally published ...
  • Favourite Films: Skyfall
    by Tom Harper Upon my recent exploration of the latest movie archives I was stopped dead in my tracks by Disney and Pixar’s recent announcem...
  • Interview: with Melissa Smith of ‘The Exonerated’
    by Taylor Richardson Melissa Smith , who plays a main role in the school’s production of The Exonerated , answers five questions surroundi...
  • Why Are We So Fascinated By The Gothic?
    Lucy Cole The Nightmare by John Henry Fuseli, 1781 (wiki commons) Since its humble beginnings in 1764, with Horace Walpole’s The Castle of O...
  • Portsmouth Point Poetry – War and Humanity in 'The Iliad'
    by George Laver  Priam (left) pleads with Achilles (centre) for the return of the body of his son, Hector (below). (source: bc.edu)    ...
  • Is Texting Killing The English Language?
    In this  TED talk , linguist John McWhorter analyses the linguistics of texting: " Texting properly isn’t writing at all — it’s actual...
  • Hackers: Pain Relief
    by Gregory Walton-Green , with an introduction by Benjamin Schofield Introduction Prompted by a writing exercise in Hackers, here Gregory ...
  • Is Lack of Sleep a Problem for PGS Pupils?
    by Hattie Gould and Annie Materna (image source: uratexblog.com) Sleep deprivation is a continual problem for teenagers and can be the caus...
  • Why The US Supreme Court Has Made The Right Decision Regarding Gene Patenting
    by Tim Bustin (source: biopoliticaltimes.org) On Thursday, the US Supreme Court ruled that human genes may not be patented, as “a naturally ...

Categories

  • Art and Literature (72)
  • Blog Exclusive (466)
  • Creative Writing (36)
  • Current Affairs (55)
  • Economics (12)
  • Film and Drama (62)
  • Food (12)
  • From Parents (1)
  • From Teachers (54)
  • Hackers (12)
  • History (21)
  • Language (17)
  • MUN (1)
  • Music (58)
  • Personal (45)
  • Philosophy and Religion (20)
  • Photography (66)
  • Psychology (13)
  • Science and Tech (41)
  • Sport (58)
  • Travel (14)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (346)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (43)
    • ►  June (52)
    • ►  May (42)
    • ►  April (41)
    • ►  March (42)
    • ▼  February (38)
      • To Meow or To Woof?
      • Visit to Ypres: February 14 and 15, 2013
      • It’s a Team Game!
      • Should We Stick to Fruit and Veg?
      • CDs and DVDs: An Obituary
      • Trompe L’œil- The Foundation of 3D Street Art?
      • The Internet: A Language of its Own?
      • Driving Disasters
      • Why You Should Avoid Penguin Poo and Country Music
      • Wavelengths
      • Valentine Poems
      • Portsmouth Point Poetry – Canzoniere I, 3
      • Why Valentine’s Day is like Richard Dawkins
      • Review: Opposites by Biffy Clyro
      • Falling Apple
      • Football Chants of the Decade
      • Natural Born Winner
      • Y.O.L.O. – A Social Death Sentence
      • The Genius of Alfred Hitchcock
      • Approaching Death in 'The Bell Jar'
      • Sylvia Plath: The Poetry’s The Thing
      • Hackers: The Year of the Snake
      • Can Arsenal Finally Win Something This Year?
      • Road to Recovery? Egypt on the Decline
      • Equal Marriage: A Victory for Progress
      • Photography Club: Legs
      • Review: 'Lincoln'
      • Happy Birthday, portsmouthpoint.blogspot.co.uk!
      • Why I Love Dickens
      • Why I Hate Dickens
      • Donna Reed- Feminist?
      • Gay Marriage: The Debate
      • Why I Am Coming Very Close To Leaving the Conserva...
      • Why Britain Should Stay In the EU
      • Why Britain Should Leave the EU
      • Visiting MoMA: Personal Highlights
      • So . . . .
      • Poem: 'Night'
    • ►  January (47)
  • ►  2012 (153)
    • ►  December (41)
    • ►  November (48)
    • ►  October (45)
    • ►  September (19)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile