PORTSMOUTHPOINT

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, October 17, 2012

‘Anna Karenina’: A Review

Posted on 11:01 PM by Unknown
by Louisa Stark



Keira Knightley as Anna Karenina
(source: thejanedough.com)




I remember seeing the trailer for the first time. The words of Tolstoy fading onto the screen, "There are as many kinds of love as there are hearts", before launching into a beautiful symphony of swirling silk, sumptuous sets, nineteenth century Russia and Keira Knightley; I practically swooned. After watching it countless times on repeat, an opportunity to see the new adaptation of Anna Karenina at the cinema came in the form of how to entertain a Swedish student, Jenny, who loved costume dramas --- perfect! Ashamedly, I am yet to read the novel, but, even without any preconceptions, my expectations were high.

Oh, how I sighed with disappointment.  The majority of the film was set in a theatre, presumably to mirror the theatricality of 19th century Russian society, against which the story of love and adultery unfolds – a seemingly inspired concept, updating a story that could easily slip into the tepid territory of traditional costume drama.  In reality, such highly choreographed set changes taking place within one space, as flamboyant and energetic as they were, conflicted completely with the story.  After all, is Anna Karenina not considered to be one of the great masterpieces of the Realist movement?  For a few brief scenes, the action strayed outside of the theatre, but the significance of these interludes was unclear, therefore losing any symbolism that had been intended.  Besides, had this been a low-budget film such ingenuity ought to be commended, but as a purely creative decision it failed.
Visually, the film was gorgeous, but what else could be expected from the director who gave us that emerald dress in Atonement and those ‘Coco Mademoiselle’ commercials? I have always been a fan of Joe Wright’s artistic eye for colour and composition alongside his storytelling, though, in this case, style triumphed over substance.  For me, the film was devoid of any emotion, which this famous tragedy could have offered; it was like flicking through the pages of Vogue: I my interest was vaguely enticed, but I was ultimately left unsatisfied.



Jude Law as Alexei Karenin
(source: steampunk.com)
As well as showing off Jacqueline Durran’s exquisite costumes to perfection, Keira Knightley’s performance as Anna was solid, though much the same as her role in the 2008 film The Duchess. The real revelation was Jude Law’s portrayal of her long-suffering husband Alexei Karenin, who managed to be unlikeable, whilst at the same time commanding almost as much sympathy as the heroine. However, this was not enough to engage or even to ebb the tedium which began to steal over me as one scene affectedly changed to the next. 
Finally, the train came. But it was at least half an hour too late, leaving in its path a tangled mess of subplots, the torn shreds of a Tolstoy novel and the fragments of a pretty perfume advert.  Contrary to the ideas of the author, “Great works of art are only great because they are accessible and comprehensible to everyone”, I found this film confusing, even as a natural English speaker, and can only imagine how Jenny was feeling by the end.  Still, I am determined to read it.  Perhaps I will give myself a few months' distance from this adaptation, but I will read Anna Karenina and this time I won’t rely on a middle-man to intervene between the text and my imagination.

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Art and Literature, Blog Exclusive, Film and Drama | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Recipe: Fifteens
     by Patrick McGuiggan The definitive Northern Ireland traybake is the ‘Fifteen’. They are so delicious I assumed that they would be fairly ...
  • 'Porphyria's Lover': A Feminist Reading
    Josh Rampton offers a Feminist reading of Robert Browning's poem 'Porphyria's Lover'. This article was originally published ...
  • Favourite Films: Skyfall
    by Tom Harper Upon my recent exploration of the latest movie archives I was stopped dead in my tracks by Disney and Pixar’s recent announcem...
  • Interview: with Melissa Smith of ‘The Exonerated’
    by Taylor Richardson Melissa Smith , who plays a main role in the school’s production of The Exonerated , answers five questions surroundi...
  • Why Are We So Fascinated By The Gothic?
    Lucy Cole The Nightmare by John Henry Fuseli, 1781 (wiki commons) Since its humble beginnings in 1764, with Horace Walpole’s The Castle of O...
  • Portsmouth Point Poetry – War and Humanity in 'The Iliad'
    by George Laver  Priam (left) pleads with Achilles (centre) for the return of the body of his son, Hector (below). (source: bc.edu)    ...
  • Is Texting Killing The English Language?
    In this  TED talk , linguist John McWhorter analyses the linguistics of texting: " Texting properly isn’t writing at all — it’s actual...
  • Hackers: Pain Relief
    by Gregory Walton-Green , with an introduction by Benjamin Schofield Introduction Prompted by a writing exercise in Hackers, here Gregory ...
  • Is Lack of Sleep a Problem for PGS Pupils?
    by Hattie Gould and Annie Materna (image source: uratexblog.com) Sleep deprivation is a continual problem for teenagers and can be the caus...
  • Why The US Supreme Court Has Made The Right Decision Regarding Gene Patenting
    by Tim Bustin (source: biopoliticaltimes.org) On Thursday, the US Supreme Court ruled that human genes may not be patented, as “a naturally ...

Categories

  • Art and Literature (72)
  • Blog Exclusive (466)
  • Creative Writing (36)
  • Current Affairs (55)
  • Economics (12)
  • Film and Drama (62)
  • Food (12)
  • From Parents (1)
  • From Teachers (54)
  • Hackers (12)
  • History (21)
  • Language (17)
  • MUN (1)
  • Music (58)
  • Personal (45)
  • Philosophy and Religion (20)
  • Photography (66)
  • Psychology (13)
  • Science and Tech (41)
  • Sport (58)
  • Travel (14)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (346)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (43)
    • ►  June (52)
    • ►  May (42)
    • ►  April (41)
    • ►  March (42)
    • ►  February (38)
    • ►  January (47)
  • ▼  2012 (153)
    • ►  December (41)
    • ►  November (48)
    • ▼  October (45)
      • The True Public Health Crisis of the 21st Century
      • Review: A Broken Rose
      • Is God responsible for everything that happens in ...
      • Review: Skyfall
      • Misunderstood Movie Villains
      • How Effective Is Our Prison System?
      • A Slice of Enlightenment – answering some of the g...
      • The 'Ginger' Issue
      • How Do You Solve a Problem Like the Euro?
      • Best and Worst Teams of the Week
      • Kick Racism Out Of Football!
      • Review: Looper
      • Review: Allelujah! Don’t Bend! Ascend! By Godspeed...
      • A Nation Mourns, But Comes of Age
      • ‘Anna Karenina’: A Review
      • President of the Internet?
      • Man Booker Prize Winner 2012: Bring Up The Bodies
      • Review: Green Day - ¡Uno!
      • 21 Things you Couldn’t Do Before You Turned Sixteen
      • Photography Club: The Eye
      • Aesthetics Are A Moral Imperative
      • Hackers: Forest of Light and Dark
      • On The Road
      • US 2012: The Latin American Dream
      • Out of the void . . . and then?
      • 'How Is There Something Rather Than Nothing?'
      • A Universe From Nothing
      • Great Gatsby: The Movie
      • Best and Worst Bond Films
      • Two Reviews of Adele's Skyfall.
      • All About Me!
      • Why The Nobel Prize System Needs To Change
      • Premier League: Best and Worst Teams of the Week
      • ICC WORLD T20: A Memorable Finish
      • Ryder Cup 2012: Greatest Comeback in Golfing History
      • Double Delight for Heroic Hampshire: Season Review...
      • In Defence of Eric Hobsbawm
      • In Memory of Amália Rodrigues: The Queen of Fado
      • With the Beatles in Portsmouth
      • US Election: How Much Is Too Much?
      • Five Reasons To Treasure The Portmuthian
      • Muse: The 2nd Law – Magnificence or Madness?
      • Portsmouth Point Poetry: Field of Autumn
      • Shakespeare: Modern Art
      • Review: Tempest by Bob Dylan
    • ►  September (19)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile