PORTSMOUTHPOINT

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, March 3, 2013

The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten

Posted on 1:05 AM by Unknown
by Freya Derby



It’s Saturday night and we’re all going to a specialist Italian restaurant, ‘La Carnivora’. The waiter shows us to our seats, next to another family with two young children. There are printed check tablecloths, olives, breadsticks and flowers on the table. The waiter asks us if we want to see the dish of the day. A cart is wheeled over to our table and lying on it is a large pig.
 ‘Good Evening’ says the pig , cheerfully.
Ah... The trouble here is that I like to eat meat and, although I occasionally feel guilty about it, it's not enough to make me a vegetarian. And anyway, pigs would end up dead even if we didn’t eat them, so is it really that wrong to bring about the inevitable just a little earlier? The waiter sighs as I deliberate.
And if I can happily eat normal meat, why do I even hesitate when presented with a pig who clearly states that he wants to be eaten? Is it an inexplicable distaste for foods I can socialise with? Is it that I’d rather have the beef? Or are we only happy to eat animals that don’t know we’re eating them?
I think that this seems likely. After all, I wouldn’t feel comfortable spending an evening with someone who I knew knew that I had plans to rob their house later that night, even if I had no guilt otherwise and knew that they wouldn’t take any preventative action. However, this implies that I think killing animals for food is wrong which, as I have already established, I don’t.  So could it still be that the pig is aware I’m going to eat it? I look at the pig who is tapping his hoof impatiently. If there was another conscious animal and I snuck up on it, and then ate it when it wasn’t looking, would it be okay?
And supposing it is okay to eat the pig, does that mean it’s fine to eat a human? Supposing an otherwise sane family member wanted to be eaten, could that be justified? Jonathan Swift suggested satirically in ‘A Modest Proposal’ that the population problem in Ireland could be solved by feeding the children of the poor to the rich. Whilst this seems an unorthodox approach to population control, one can’t deny that it has its advantages, an idea I ponder as I survey the table next to us, which contains the irritating but plump children…
…Still I personally would draw the line before eating a child. No matter how plump…
So should I only eat animals that are unaware I’m going to eat them? Although it’s confusing and I can’t decide… I am pretty hungry…
Thank you to Douglas Adams for ruining my meal.

See, also, Should We Stick to Fruit and Veg? by Lucy Cole
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Blog Exclusive, Food | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Recipe: Fifteens
     by Patrick McGuiggan The definitive Northern Ireland traybake is the ‘Fifteen’. They are so delicious I assumed that they would be fairly ...
  • 'Porphyria's Lover': A Feminist Reading
    Josh Rampton offers a Feminist reading of Robert Browning's poem 'Porphyria's Lover'. This article was originally published ...
  • Favourite Films: Skyfall
    by Tom Harper Upon my recent exploration of the latest movie archives I was stopped dead in my tracks by Disney and Pixar’s recent announcem...
  • Interview: with Melissa Smith of ‘The Exonerated’
    by Taylor Richardson Melissa Smith , who plays a main role in the school’s production of The Exonerated , answers five questions surroundi...
  • Why Are We So Fascinated By The Gothic?
    Lucy Cole The Nightmare by John Henry Fuseli, 1781 (wiki commons) Since its humble beginnings in 1764, with Horace Walpole’s The Castle of O...
  • Portsmouth Point Poetry – War and Humanity in 'The Iliad'
    by George Laver  Priam (left) pleads with Achilles (centre) for the return of the body of his son, Hector (below). (source: bc.edu)    ...
  • Is Lack of Sleep a Problem for PGS Pupils?
    by Hattie Gould and Annie Materna (image source: uratexblog.com) Sleep deprivation is a continual problem for teenagers and can be the caus...
  • Why The US Supreme Court Has Made The Right Decision Regarding Gene Patenting
    by Tim Bustin (source: biopoliticaltimes.org) On Thursday, the US Supreme Court ruled that human genes may not be patented, as “a naturally ...
  • Is Conscience Innate or Learned?
    by Oliver Price (source: adorotedevote.blogspot.com) Developmental pyschologist Jean Piaget put forward the theory that conscience is learne...
  • Doctor Who Series 7: Massive Disappointment
    by Melissa Smith Nice fez (image source: doctorwhotv.co.uk) I’d like to start off with a disclaimer: I have been an avid fan of Doctor Who ...

Categories

  • Art and Literature (72)
  • Blog Exclusive (466)
  • Creative Writing (36)
  • Current Affairs (55)
  • Economics (12)
  • Film and Drama (62)
  • Food (12)
  • From Parents (1)
  • From Teachers (54)
  • Hackers (12)
  • History (21)
  • Language (17)
  • MUN (1)
  • Music (58)
  • Personal (45)
  • Philosophy and Religion (20)
  • Photography (66)
  • Psychology (13)
  • Science and Tech (41)
  • Sport (58)
  • Travel (14)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (346)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (43)
    • ►  June (52)
    • ►  May (42)
    • ►  April (41)
    • ▼  March (42)
      • Social Acceptance: The Tyranny of the Majority
      • Easter Sunday Gospel Hour: The Staple Singers
      • 'Be My Baby': A Director's View
      • Photography Club: Self Portraits
      • Good Friday or Forgiveness Friday?
      • Translation of Literature: Challenge, Sacrifice an...
      • England: What To Do?
      • Theatre Review: South Downs
      • Boris Johnson: The Irresistible Rise
      • Review: Tegan and Sara – Heartthrob
      • Formula One: Australia Race Review
      • 5 Things I Can't Live Without
      • The Budget 2013: Another Nail in the Tory Coffin
      • The Budget 2013: Will It Increase Growth?
      • The Budget 2013: No Plan B, No Recovery.
      • A Reason For Running
      • A Worthwhile War? The West's Struggle to Secure Iraq
      • Why The Iraq War Was Wrong
      • PGS Model United Nations Conference 2013
      • My Top Four Embarrassments
      • Images from PGS MUN Conference 2013
      • PGS MUN Conference 2013: A Year 6 Experience
      • Ides of March Lecture: 'Ancient Egypt: From the Py...
      • The Power of Perseverance
      • Un Héroe Local En Un Mundo de Héroes Internacionales
      • Ode to Southern Rail
      • Ultrasound in Medicine
      • Learning Life Lessons from ‘How I Met Your Mother’
      • Review: 'The Next Day' by David Bowie
      • Photography: Winter Fights Back
      • 10 Things That Make This Papal Conclave So Unpredi...
      • High Street Elegy
      • Photography: Sunshine at PGS
      • Hugo Chavez: Man of Contradictions
      • Can Women Have It All?
      • What 2013 Holds for the Gaming Industry.
      • The Travelling Diaries 2: Trains
      • Bram Stoker's Fifty Shades of Dorian Gray: Part II
      • The Best (and Worst) Drummers of All Time
      • The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten
      • Eastleigh: A Tory Reacts
      • Was 2012 the Pinnacle of British Cycling or Is The...
    • ►  February (38)
    • ►  January (47)
  • ►  2012 (153)
    • ►  December (41)
    • ►  November (48)
    • ►  October (45)
    • ►  September (19)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile